If this is the case, then the thesis could, for example, center around the diversity of issues scholars have chosen to examine or the fractured nature of scholarship on the topic.: Your thesis statement should include the rationale for why the key points you highlight or compare and contrast among the books being reviewed were deliberate and meaningful and not random. Organization is critical to writing an essay that compares and contrasts multiple works because you will most likely be discussing a variety of evidence and you must be certain that the logic and narrative flow of your paper can be understood by the reader. Front matter is most often numbered separately from the rest of the text in lower case Roman numerals [i.e. Critical commentary about front or back matter is generally only necessary if you believe there is something that diminishes the overall quality of the work [e.g., the indexing is poor] or there is something that is particularly helpful in understanding the book's contents [e.g., foreword places the book in an important context].: Typically, multiple book review essays do not compare and contrast the quality of the back and front matter unless the books share a common deficiency [e.g., poor indexing] or the front or back matter is particularly important in supplementing the primary content of the books.
Here are some general guidelines to consider: There are two general methods of organizing your book review essay. Your conclusion should synthesize the key similarities and differences among the books and their collective contributions to understanding of the research problem. “Reading and Writing Book Reviews Across the Disciplines.” 57 (July 2006): 1194-1207; Hooker, Fran and Kate James. University of Toronto; Writing a Compare/Contrast Essay.
In fact, your paper will be more interesting if you state your main argument(s) as quickly as possible.
For example, a book review essay evaluating three research studies that examine different interpretations of conflict resolution among nations in the Middle East might have as few as two or three sentences in the introduction regarding similarities and only a paragraph or two to set up the contrast between the author’s positions.
An important first step in approaching how to write a review of two or more books is to identify and think critically about the research problem that ties each of the books together. Princeton Writing Program; Rhetorical Strategies: Comparison and Contrast. Hunter College; Visvis, Vikki and Jerry Plotnick; Writing a Compare/Contrast Essay. It should include the argument that will be advanced in support of the claims that are being made.
This information is usually summarized in the preface or introductory chapter of the book. “Reading and Writing Book Reviews Across the Disciplines.” 57 (July 2006): 1194-1207; Walk, Kerry. To begin, ask yourself: "What is the overarching subject or issue that ties together all of the books? " In most scholarly works, the author(s) will state the purpose of their book in the preface or in an introductory chapter.
Telling these four elements to your classmates would give them a complete, yet summarized, picture of the theory, so they could apply the theory in future discussions.
Although you did this verbally, you were still fulfilling the elements of an expository essay by providing definition, details, explanations, and maybe even facts if you have a really good memory.
The rest of the essay, whether organized by block method or point-by-point, will be your analysis of the key differences among the books. Briefly introduce significance of overall subject matter B.
Present all the information about A, and then present parallel information about B. Briefly introduce the significance of the overall subject matter B. Briefly summarize how you proved your argument Present one point about A, and then go to the parallel point about B. This pattern tends to work better for long book review essays and those with many sub-topics.